There's No Place Better - EMRR! EMRR Rocks!
the basic, real and invariable nature of a thing!

 

Guests On
(EMRR is Off)
  myEMRR
[Logo]

Mon Aug 25 13:39:36 2008 

Art Applewhite
Cone Rocket 18mm
P.O.Box 294064
Kerrville, TX 78028
 
  All   More Like This   Previous   Next

SPECS: 4.5" x 3.9" - 1.0 oz
ROCKSIM FILE: MISSING - please submit here
SpaceCAD FILE: MISSING - please submit here
REC'D MOTORS: A8-3, B4-2, B6-2, B6-4, C6-3, C6-5

[Picture](08/01/03) Here's a new twist in Art Applewhite's UFO-series of rockets.... the Cone Rocket! I'm calling it a Cone UFO just to keep with the theme of what Art Applewhite Rockets seems to have a knack (and niche) in.

This is the 18mm Orange version. There are also 13mm, 24mm, and 29mm versions in Stars & Stripes, Mirror Gold, Silver, Yellow and Texas Special.


Rocket Pic  Rocket Pic

Also, in keeping with what Art Applewhite does best, this is a straightforward kit with very few parts. It has more parts than his standard UFO and Delta UFO, but still it is a rocket that can be assembled in about 1 hour. The kit includes a 18mm motor mount tube, a 19mm nose cone tube, a 36" round-elastic shock cord, color/design cardstock for top and reinforcing Strip, cardstock for the nose cone, shock cord anchor, and engine block, and finally foam-board, with preprinted patterns for the nosecone base and the bottom.

CONSTRUCTION:

The instructions are printed on 4 pages of 8½ x 11" paper. They include black and white photos to assist in the building process. The tools and supplies that are needed are outlined: Scissors, #11 Exacto® Knife, Elmer's Glue-All®, 5-Minute Epoxy and 220 girt sandpaper. You are then warned to read through the entire instructions before beginning. I agree.

Assembly is described in a logical order and I had no issues building this rocket, except one. Be sure you have your two motor tubes before you start. My 18mm tube was slid into my 19mm tube and I never realized that I needed two tubes until I got to the steps requiring the second tube. I found mine, inside the other and it is a very good thing that no glue had gotten on it!

The instructions have you build the two sections of the Cone UFO. First you cut out the nose cone from the cardstock. This is then formed and glued. This is actually an inner support structure verse what we think of as traditional nose cones. A unique support method for this paper rocket. This nose cone takes all the ejection abuse. It also provided the nose weight needed for stability. Once the cone is formed it is filled to a described level with 5-minute epoxy. The inside is also coated with epoxy to strengthen it. Then after cutting out the nose cone base from the 1/4" foam board and using JUST the 19mm tube, the remainder of the nose cone is assembled. The shockcord is also attached here between the 19mm tube and the foam board base.

The foam board is cut the same as on Art Applewhite's other UFO's. Using your hobby knife, cut out the patterns. Cut out the centers to make the motor mount holes and the launch rod holes. Then the most difficult part of construction; cutting the bevel edge on the outside edges. This has to be done twice on this Cone UFO; for the nose cone base and for the bottom. Be sure to use a new blade and take your time. Doing those two things makes this a lot easier than it sounds.

The colored cardstock is then used to cut out the cone (body) and the reinforcing ring. The cone body is formed using a glue tab. Then the nose cone that was initially assembled is installed into the tip of the colored cone body. This really adds strength and the weight to the rocket's nose as well as helps in forming a nice tip.

The bottom is simply the 1/4" foam board with the 18mm motor mount attached; flush to the bottom. The thrust ring is added by cutting the long strip from the cardstock, rolling it, and gluing it into the motor tube. There are also good instructions to ensure that you have a nice fit for the 18mm tube into the 19mm tube.

Lastly the shockcord is mounted to the bottom using the 3-fold paper method. That's it.

Art Applewhite Rockets indicates you may paint the rocket or at "a minimum you should apply at least two light coats of clear enamel" to protect the rocket. I passed.

Overall, for CONSTRUCTION I would rate this kit 4 ½ points. Because my two tubes were shipped inside each other, I could have run into a real problem. Yes, there is a parts picture that shows two tubes, but I'm sure like many builders, I just dug right into it. Perhaps the note in step 7 should be expanded to say, "if the 18mm tube is in the 19mm tube, separate them now". I'm being hypercritical here!

A8-3B6-4FLIGHT/RECOVERY:

Art Applewhite recommends an A8-3, B4-2, B6-2, B6-4, C6-3 or C6-5 for flying the 18mm Cone UFO. The motors are to be friction fit into the motor mount and flush with the thrust ring. The rocket is expected to weigh 1 ounce. My rocket weighed 0.9 ounces.

Flight preparation includes sliding the 18mm motor mount into the 19mm nose cone tube. Then pushing the shockcord into the rocket, opposite side of the launch rod holes, before pushing the bottom flush with the cone tube.

I have flow the 18mm version 3 times in my front yard. Yes, this is a nice feature of these UFO rockets. They can be front (or back) yard rockets since they get very little altitude. I flew mine on an A8-3, then a B6-4, and then an A8-3 again.

DescentAll the flights were the stable. They all went straight up, inverted to start descent and then, based on the delay, popped the ejection charge. The A8-3 needs to be an A8-1 if you were to eject at apogee. Also, since you get maybe 50 feet of altitude on the A8, the ejection charge can be quite loud. It startled my wife on the first one!

The B6-4 could stand a 2 or 3 second delay to eject at apogee.

My third flight (A8-3) kicked the motor out at ejection with some force. Be sure it is in tight. Since the ejection volume is so little, it has a lot of pressure, and can make that motor a hot, flying projectile.

All three flights also demonstrated the success of the tumble recovery system. I even caught a picture of it falling!

For FLIGHT/RECOVERY, I would rate this rocket 5 points. Flights are low and slow. Makes it a good demo rocket. You don't need wadding. Overall, a unique looking and fun flying rocket.

Landed

I give the rocket an OVERALL rating of 5 points. Other than my hypercritical comments, I see this as a "perfect" rocket for its price, instructions, assembly and flight characteristics. I may have to go purchase a 29mm one for some fun with EconoJets!


Rating
(Contributed - by Blake Eric DeMarcy - 08/03/08)

Brief:
This is a conical design offered by Art Applewhite [Author's Home Page]. It flies straight as any other rocket.

Construction:
When I got the kit, it had 2 body tubes. One was 18mm and the other was 19mm. The kit also had 2 sheets of cardstock, a piece of foamboard with pre-printed markings, 36 inches of elastic, and instructions.

Construction is covered by the above review.

Finishing:
You should spray a coat of clear on your cone, but if you get gold like I did, this is not needed.

Construction Rating: 5 out of 5

Flight:
The cone has flown 23 times to date, but it seems, as hard as I try, the motor always kicks out the mount. Trust me, I try my best every time to retain the motor! The cone is a great performer on C6 motors but is still cool on a B6 motor.

Recovery:
The cone pops in two pieces held together by elastic. Descent is slow and safe. No wadding needed. However, I will ding half a point because I can't keep the motor in the cone no matter how hard I try.

Flight Rating: 4 ½ out of 5

Summary:
The cone is my favorite rocket and has held up well for all those flights. The cone landed on a variety of hard surfaces--asphalt, metal roofs, sidewalks, even landing on the football goal once--and survived to fly again. Buy one, you won't be dissapointed!

Overall Rating: 5 out of 5

[Submit your Opinion]

GUEST's OPINION:
09/03 - "I was going to write a full review, but the EMRR review is so thorough mine would be mostly redundant, so here is a quick mini-review. Construction: This is my second Applewhite cone rocket, so I learned from my mistakes on the first one and did not have much trouble building this one. I absolutely agree with the EMRR review that a sharp knife is critical when cutting the bevels in the foam board. When building the inside nose cone, several parts need to be smeared with 5-minute epoxy and then fit together before it sets. Practice fitting the parts together before mixing any epoxy, because it sets up quicker than you think. I had a little trouble rolling my own thrust ring out of the provided card stock getting it to fit cleanly into the motor mount tube. I ended up using a standard engine block from another kit. Construction: 4.5 Flight: Flights were great, with lots of smoke trapped in the base vortex. Lower and slower than a conventional rocket, but much faster than most saucers. As noted, the ejection is very loud with such a small body to pressurize and ejection occurring so close to the ground. Flights: 5.0 Overall: Great value for the money." (B.C.)

GUEST's OPINION:
08/03 - "HEY, someone beat me to the punch! I built a 24mm cone and will submit a review once I get to a launch. I generally agree with Nick's construction rating, but will deduct a half point because the cone is harder to form that his saucers' shrouds, and I wanted to make a distinction. Now I'm thinking drag race if similarly sized and powered cones, Deltas, and standard saucers could be scraped up. " (D.S.)

[Enter Rocket Specific Tip]

SPECIFIC ROCKET TIP:
10/03 - "If you extend the motor mount below the end of the rocket be very careful. The rocket is very stable if built according to the instructions. It is however a very short rocket and any rearward shift in the CG will make this and any other rocket less stable in flight. Art Applewhite" (A.A. )

SPECIFIC ROCKET TIP:
09/03 - "When attaching the motor tube to the bottom plate, let it stick out the bottom by 1/4 inch. Use this exposed surface to tape the motor in place to prevent kicking the motor at ejection. Much easier engine removal after a flight than friction fitting." (B.C. )

[Enter Flight Log]           Don't see your recently submitted flight log? Click Here
Date Name Motor Ejection/
Altitude
Wind Notes
09-28-2003 Bob Cox Est SU B6-4 Just Past (1-2sec) Calm Spaceship Earth - Twilight launch. Beautiful straight boost. Smoke and sparks trapped in wake vortex. LOUD ejection 2 sec past apogee, with comet-like trail of glowing ejection debris falling alongside rocket. Recovered safe; only minor discoloration of shock cord.
01-02-2005 Bob Cox Est SU C6-3 Just Past (1-2sec) 5-10 mph winds Spaceship Earth MkII - One large wiggle after leaving rod, then nice gentle arcing boost. Slowed down quickly after burnout. After ejection, the lower half fell side-by-side with upper half. Hard landing on frozen field, but no damage to epoxy-filled tip.
09-18-2005 Bob Cox Est SU A10-3 None - Tumble 0-5 mph winds Spaceship Earth MkII - Straight up, then straight down, descending TAIL_FIRST until the ejection charge popped about halfway down. Never seen it do that before.
09-24-2006 Bob Cox Est SU B4-2 Apogee - Perfect 5-10 mph winds Event: High School C
Spaceship Earth MkII - Nice boost with very slight wiggle. Popped at apogee and fluttered to gentle landing on grass. 9 sec.
09-28-2003 Bob Cox Est SU C6-3 Just Past (1-2sec) Calm RIPEvent: Twilight Launch II
Spaceship Earth - Tilted rod a bit -- bad idea. Long curving boost. LOUD ejection 1 sec past apogee, with lots of glowing ejection debris. Descended gently and landed in 75 foot tree. Status: Tree/Roof
05-10-2008 Blake De+Marcy Est SU C6-3 Just Past (1-2sec) 0-5 mph winds - Second flight. Arrow-straight launch that could not posibbly be better! No damage.
05-11-2008 Blake De+Marcy Qst SU C6-5 Very Late 0-5 mph winds - This rocket actually flew 20+ times but i am not going to even TRY to log all of them. This landed on a metal roof but a plastic bottle + good aim is a great combo!
05-10-2008 Blake DeMarcy Est SU B6-4 Just Past (1-2sec) 0-5 mph winds - First Flight. Slight wiggle from pad but straightened and flew at slight angle. LOUD ejection about 30 feet from ground. no damage and will fly again!
07-04-2008 Blake DeMarcy Est SU C6-3 Apogee - NC Down 0-5 mph winds - Flight 20: Launched on the fourth of July. Loud ejection pop blended well with the surrounding fireworks. No damage
07-25-2008 Blake DeMarcy Est SU C6-3 Apogee - NC Down 0-5 mph winds - Flight 21. Was it just me, or did this go WAYYYYYYYY faster than normal? WARNING!: CONINICAL LIGHTNING BOLT! recovered right outside field. no damage.
07-25-2008 Blake DeMarcy Est SU C6-3 Apogee - NC Down 0-5 mph winds - Flight 22. nominal. no damage
07-25-2008 Blake DeMarcy Est SU C6-3 Apogee - NC Down 0-5 mph winds - flight 23. no damage
07-31-2003 EMRR Est SU A8-3 Just Past (1-2sec) Calm Orange - A successful first flight. Straight up. Started down and then a loud pop of the ejection. Good recovery
07-31-2003 EMRR Est SU A8-3 Just Past (1-2sec) Calm Orange - Repeat of first flight!
07-31-2003 EMRR Est SU B6-4 Just Past (1-2sec) Calm Orange - Second flight, higher but a repeat in performance. Mayby 70-80 feet high.
08-28-2003 EMRR Est SU A8-3 Apogee - Perfect Calm Orange - Very nice. This is another enjoyable backyard rocket
06-05-2005 EMRR Est SU B4-2 Apogee - Perfect Calm Orange - Fast flight. Loud pop upon ejection. I like it!
08-16-2003 Dan Westley Est SU C6-3 Just Past (1-2sec) 0-5 mph winds Gold - 2nd flight. Couple of kids had gathered to watch. Great flight, just like the 1st.
08-16-2003 Dan Westley Est SU C6-3 Just Past (1-2sec) 0-5 mph winds Gold - 3rd flight, loads of kids now gathered as audience, so I *had* to launch again. Audience were not dissapointed. BIG flash from ejection charge, which went down well! Kicked out motor, again.
08-16-2003 Dan Westley Est SU C6-3 Just Past (1-2sec) 0-5 mph winds Gold - Maiden flight, delayed due to faulty ignitor clips. Loads of smoke & noise. Landed 10m from pad, ejected motor at apogee.
 

Please Help Make Us Better!   

•  Copyright ©1998-2008  •   EMRR   •   Legal/Privacy   •   Disclaimer   •