| Construction Rating: |      | | Flight Rating: |      | | Overall Rating: |      |
Contributed by Chan Stevens
Brief:
Based on the Mars Lander design, this is clearly one of the best-looking
designs of Estes 2004 fleet. I really wanted to like this. Really.
Unfortunately, this great design was very poorly executed and the result is a
very disappointing performer. At nearly $30 retail, I can't recommend this kit
unless it's for display and being built by someone with considerable patience.
If you really want to build this one, you'd better buy two, as the first once
will be chalked up to a learning experience.
Construction:
The hefty price is because of the parts list. This has lots and lots of parts.
BT-60 tubing for the main body (6" and 2"), a BT20 motor mount tube
(more on this later), 4 large BT-50 tanks (3" each), 8 smaller tanks
(BT-20 x 1.5"), a molded plastic combo transition/nozzle/nose cone, balsa,
dowels, lots of cardboard rings and end caps, a beautiful sheet of decals, and
assorted hardware and recovery gear.
I honestly don't think this rocket was built by the person writing the
instructions. I'm not sure it was ever built prior to release, period. While
the instructions were generally clear and accurate, there were a couple of
mistakes and the suggested techniques result in a very flimsy construction job.
The instructions carry a warning/suggestion that if you want to follow the
standard color scheme, you should paint several parts before assembly (legs,
tanks, body tubes, plastic parts and "gear box assembly"). I really
liked the color scheme on the header card (base of blue with red and silver
accents/trim), so I went with the paint-before-assembly plan.
Construction starts with cutting the dowels used to trim the landing gear.
The template calls out some very specific angles, which were hard to match, but
minor errors are not critical. Next, the dowels are inserted into flexible
rubber tubing that acts as a hinge, with a small plastic BB inserted into the
center as a stop.
The rest of the landing gear is assembled from balsa leg center sections
and cardboard trim pieces. The feet are very short centering rings with a
couple of cardboard disks for caps. Pay very close attention to the
instructions, which clearly show which disks to use for this step--there are
several different sizes involved, and they can easily be mixed up if you're not
careful. Once completed, the leg assemblies are then painted red/blue/silver.
After completing the leg assembly, the "gear housing" covers are
made from a couple of balsa covers with a pair of small balsa spacers
sandwiched between. The instructions note to paint this after assembly, though
I found it nearly impossible to paint the inside area very well.
The plastic parts need to be cut apart from a single mold then trimmed. The
cut lines were not well marked, although fairly well illustrated in the
instructions. This was tough plastic and I chewed through a fresh blade on
this. Most of the plastic parts are then painted.
The motor mount assembly requires some patience and correction of minor
problems. The centering rings are mounted to fairly precise dimensions, and
this is on purpose. There's also a 2" dowel that is mounted on the tube to
keep the rings aligned, but this dowel is incorrectly sized, and needs to be
1-7/16" long instead. Otherwise, the rings won't fit to spec. The
centering ring alignment and spacing is critical because they serve as mounting
points for the landing gear.
With 12 different tubes and each getting cardboard disk end caps, the tank
assemblies are simple but time consuming. If you want a great-looking finish,
filling these spirals will drive you nuts. Here's a tip though: since only one
side of the tanks are visible and mostly covered by decals, only a light
filling of one side is necessary. Finished tanks are then painted silver. I
would also recommend applying the decals after painting rather than after they
are mounted.
Next, the body tubes are marked with lots of lines. Tank alignment lines,
leg housing lines, launch lug lines, etc. Wait a minute. Aren't these the tubes
I'm PAINTING before assembly?! What good does marking do when the marks get
covered with paint?! This is boneheaded. You have to choose to either align
things by eye after paint, mark a painted tube and try to hide the lines after
assembly, or mark, assemble, then paint, which in my opinion would be
enormously difficult. I did at least use the tube marking guide to cut out the
sections for the legs to slip through.
Once the body tubes are marked/painted(???), the gear housing is attached.
Since I painted, I had to tack it on with a couple of drops of CA. I can't
think of anything else better for bonding painted wood-based parts, but if
anyone reading this has a better idea, post it as a comment. The CA bond is not
a very strong one.
After bonding the gear housing to the motor tube, the legs are secured with
elastic, and then kept in place by slots in the nozzle, which caps the end of
the BT-20. Cardboard caps cover the slots, securing the legs in the housing.
Construction wraps up by gluing the upper body tube to the BT-20 motor tube
assembly, then attaching the tanks to the upper and lower body tubes. Again,
with painted surfaces, I found myself tacking these on with CA and given my
lack of alignment lines, this was very difficult getting everything to fit. The
ascent module (large plastic transition section) slides over the upper body
tube, capped by the nose cone/end cap.
Finishing:
I don't know whether to ding the finishing or the construction, but bonding a
large, heavy, clunky rocket on painted surfaces is a very bad idea. Painting
such intricate details, with lots of nooks and crannies after assembly is also
a very bad idea. I'm leaning towards dinging the construction but not the
finish, because after building, this is a very cool looking rocket.
Construction Rating:
3
out of 5
Flight:
Wrapping up construction, I picked up the very heavy (over 4 ounce) rocket, and
couldn't believe it was using an 18mm motor. (Ignoring Aerotech's hard-to-find
18mm D motors, this meant using a C6-3.) I think this is seriously underpowered
on a C6-3 and the only reason I can think that Estes would also recommend B4-2
or B6-2's would be for flying in a school gymnasium. Heck, you could even go
with an A8-3 and fly it in your living room, assuming you have vaulted
ceilings! (Note to kids: don't try this at home! I was only kidding.)
The first flight, on a beautiful but breezy (8-10mph winds) day was with a
C6-3. As I called for the heads up flight, I feared the wind and weathercock
would prove more than the puny C6 could overcome. Sure enough, about 25 feet
up, the Outlander veered into the wind at a nearly 90 degree path, peaking at
about 75-80 feet up but 50 yards out. The 18" plastic chute deployed about
10 feet off the ground, and the crash landing wiped out 2 of the 4 fins/legs
and one of the tanks.
The repairs won't be too bad, but this clearly can't handle any kind of
wind at all.
Recovery:
PROs: landed close to the bad, don't have to worry about busting the ceiling on
our waiver...
CONs: horribly underpowered, unstable in moderate winds.
Flight Rating:
1
out of 5
Summary:
Great looking design, but destined to be a static display only unless it is
upgraded to 24mm motors.
Overall Rating:
2
out of 5 Flight Log| Date | Rocket Name | Motor(s) | Altitude | Notes |
|---|
| 2004-02-12 | Donald Besaw's Estes Outlander | C6-3 | - | Nice first flight, slow liftoff and boost to maybe 150 feet tops and deployed the chute 50-75 feet... | | 2004-04-24 | Donald Besaw's Estes Outlander | C6-3 | - | Nice flight up to about 150 feet. Recovered nice and slow on an Estes 24 inch chute although it... | | 2004-04-24 | Chan Stevens's Estes Outlander | C6-3 | - | Horribly underpowered, deployed about 15 feet off ground | | 2004-05-08 | Jason Lenentine's Estes Outlander | E9-4 | - | Flight 3. Great boost on E9-4! Parachute snarrled on the rocket. No chute. Landed feet first... | | 2004-05-08 | Jason Lenentine's Estes Outlander | D12-3 | - | Second flight was repeat of flight #1. Same grass kept it from sticking the landing. | | 2004-06-05 | David Logan's Estes Outlander | E9-4 | - | Perfect motor for this rocket. Flew to about 400 feet. Recovered using a 20 inch nylon chute with... | | 2004-06-26 | David Logan's Estes Outlander | E9-4 | - | another great flight on the E9 motor. Landed on it's side in some waist high grass about 150 feet... | | 2004-07-16 | Jason Lenentine's Estes Outlander | D12-3 | - | First flight after repairing broken legs and housings. Another great boost and chute deployment,... | | 2004-08-04 | Tim Anderson's Estes Outlander | C6-4 | - | should have a ejection delay of 2 instead of 3, still with the nose heading down by the time it... | | 2004-08-04 | Tim Anderson's Estes Outlander | C6-3 | - | rocked got windcocked from the get go even with little to no wind. even after a VERY late... | | 2004-08-04 | Tim Anderson's Estes Outlander | A8-3 | 5 feet | Tried A8-3 Engine for a picture,Rocket left launch post then fell to the ground and ejected there. | | 2004-09-05 | Jason Lenentine's Estes Outlander | E9-4 | - | Field size and winds were marginal for this one today. Pushed my luck but was rewarded with a... | | 2004-12-02 | Jason Lenentine's Estes Outlander | E9-4 | - | Good flight. | | 2004-12-02 | Jason Lenentine's Estes Outlander | E9-4 | - | Always a fun flight on an E9. | | 2004-12-03 | Donald Besaw's Estes Outlander | C6-3 | - | Beautiful slow and straight flight, deployed the chute just as it began to turn over and head back... | | 2005-03-06 | Jason Lenentine's Estes Outlander | D12-3 | - | Another great boost for this one, but the landings stink. This time the plastic tubing connecting... | | 2005-04-17 | Bob Harrington's Estes Outlander | D12-3 | - | Engine blast off deflector plate burned through elastic cord holding leg and one leg ripped off.... | | 2005-05-04 | Donald Laskey's Estes Outlander | B6-2 | - | | | 2005-05-15 | David Logan's Estes Outlander | E9-4 | - | another perfect flight, landed about 50 yards from pads using a 22 inch chute with spill hole. | | 2005-05-29 | John Caramagna's Estes Outlander | C6-3 | - | Followup to the B-6 launch. Vehicle boosted to about 10-12 feet then turned parallel to ground... | | 2005-05-29 | John Caramagna's Estes Outlander | B6-2 | - | Slow lift-off but very straight to about 40 feet (?). Chute ejected well but shroud line tangled... | | 2005-06-18 | John Caramagna's Estes Outlander | C6-3 | - | Thought it would work better with longer launch rod. Assumed last engine was faulty but could not... | | 2005-06-18 | Larry Zeilmann's Outlander | C11-3 | - | Perfect flight, good chute, low altitude, no damage. | | 2005-06-23 | Donald Besaw's Estes Outlander | C5-3 | - | Very nice flight, flew great on this motor. Too bad Estes doesn't make these anymore. Recovered... | | 2005-06-25 | Jason Lenentine's Estes Outlander | E9-4 | - | Perfect boost with good 4 point landing. | | 2005-06-25 | Jason Lenentine's Estes Outlander | E9-4 | - | Another good boost -- didn't stick the landing. | | 2005-06-25 | Jason Lenentine's Estes Outlander | F21-4 | - | Holy cow. Whatta crazy fun flight. Insane boost on White Lightning. One gear housing shredded... | | 2005-07-16 | Steve Fisher's Estes Outlander | B6-4 | - | 2nd attempt of this rocket. Perfect arch and chute deployment. Not to high but landed with a... | | 2005-07-16 | Steve Fisher's Estes Outlander | B6-4 | - | 1st flight. Chute got tangled on deployment. Landed on side. No damage. Will retry. | | 2005-10-22 | Bob Harrington's Estes Outlander | D12-3 | - | Nice boost. Chute was slightly scorched and only partially opened. The landing was hard and a leg... | | 2005-10-29 | Chris Guidry's Estes Outlander | D13-4 | - | Nice flight but chute scorched and did not open. Minimal damage. Repairable. | | 2005-11-30 | Jon Revelle's Estes Outlander | C6-3 | - | Parachute tangled with leg and came down fast. Broke the rubber leg joint tube thing. Not worth... | | 2005-12-23 | Jason Lenentine's Estes Outlander | E18-4 | - | Insane boost! Marvelous smoke and flame. Perfect four point landing, but bounced back into the... | | 2006-03-18 | Larry Zeilmann's Outlander | D12-3 | - | Burn through shock cord, major damage, brocken legs, being repaired | | 2006-04-01 | Lance Souther's Estes Outlander | E9-4 | - | Awesome flight on this motor...at least 700 feet. I used two 18 chutes. It landed on all 4 but... | | 2006-04-01 | Lance Souther's Estes Outlander | D12-3 | - | Nice flight nearly straight up...guessing about 375 feet. Used 24 nylon parachute, landed a... | | 2006-04-29 | Clive Davis's Estes Outlander | D12-3 | - | Modified to fly on 24 mm motors. Added some clay to nose. Flight was picture perfect straight... | | 2006-05-28 | Chris Kraemer's Estes Outlander | C6-3 | - | Good second flight - late parachute ejection | | 2006-05-28 | Chris Kraemer's Estes Outlander | C6-3 | - | Rocket canted over immediately after leaving lauch rod. Crashed prior to parachute ejection. ... | | 2006-06-24 | Jason Lenentine's Estes Outlander | D12-3 | - | Good flight, landed on all fours in tall grass but toppled over. I think I typed this flight log... | | 2006-07-29 | Glenn Weiss's Estes Outlander | C6-3 | - | Good first flight, boosted 150-200 ft, at ejection one parachute shroud line snapped so it did not... | | 2006-08-22 | Clive Davis's Estes Outlander | D12-5 | - | Boost was good. 3 second delay would have been better. One of the legs snapped off on landing. ... | | 2006-10-07 | Geof Givens's Estes Outlander | D12-3 | - | Modified for 24mm and 1oz nose weight. Action-filled flight (but totally stable) with slight arc... | | 2006-11-11 | Geof Givens's Estes Outlander | D12-3 | - | Wife swore NC was too tight. She was right. Core sample utter devastation. Can't even count the... | | 2006-11-25 | Glenn Weiss's Estes Outlander | D21-4 | - | Awesome loud and fast boost on the D21! Came down gently but with the slight wind did not stick... | | 2007-03-31 | Glenn Weiss's Estes Outlander | C6-3 | - | A complete disaster. Ejected maybe 10ft. above ground and core sampled, causing serious internal... | | 2008-01-13 | Jon Chrisman's Estes Outlander | D10-3 | - | Sputtered on the pad, but once motor fully lit made a nice arching flight to about 200 feet..Crowd... | | 2009-06-20 | Kathy Miller's Estes Outlander | D12-3 | - | | 2009-09-12  | Kathy Miller's Estes Outlander | D12-5 | - | | | 2009-11-07 | Cliff Oliver's Estes Outlander | D21-4 | - | | 2012-02-26  | Stephen Fitton's Outlander | C5-3 | 200 feet | Textbook flight with slow liftoff, very steady boost with very slight inclination into the wind. ... | 2012-03-10  | Stephen Fitton's Outlander | C5-3 | 150 feet | Another low but very nice flight |
Comments: - Post a Comment -
eBay Offers: ESTES ROCKET MODEL OUTLANDER 2110 - OUT OF PRODUCTION - NEW VINTAGE >>> Product Details >>> ** LOT OF 3 ESTES MODEL ROCKET KITS ** PATRIOT-OUTLANDER-BIG BERTHA ** >>> Product Details >>>
What You Can Do
- Link to this Page -
You can link to this page using the following HTML or BB Code.
Text Link in HTML (for web sites)
<a href="http://www.rocketreviews.com/estes-industries-outlander-by-chan-stevens.html">Estes - Outlander (2110) [2003-2008] - Review by Chan Stevens</a>
Text Link in BB Code (for forum posts)
[url=http://www.rocketreviews.com/estes-industries-outlander-by-chan-stevens.html]Estes - Outlander (2110) [2003-2008] - Review by Chan Stevens[/url]
Select the appropriate above text with your mouse then "right-click" and select "Copy." Then, paste the text into your web site's code or a discussion forum post.
|
J.R. ()