Reviews >>

4-Star ReviewsEstes Product Reviews (124 of 608)Kit ReviewsReviews by John R. Brandon IIIReviews of Estes - X-Prize Rubicon

Estes - X-Prize Rubicon

Manufacturer:

Estes

Construction Rating:
Flight Rating:
Overall Rating:

Contributed by John R. Brandon III

Brief:
A single-staged D-powered scale representation of the Space Transportation Corporation's entry in the competition for the Ansari X-Prize.

Construction:
The rocket kit consisted of a 24mm motor mount tube, a motor block ring, a motor retainer hook, a thick stage coupler-like hook retainer ring, six tank tubes, a large main body tube, a truly massive blow molded plastic nose cone, a set of six plastic fins, a plastic fin canister, a plastic bulkhead, an assembled plastic 18" parachute, a set of six plastic nozzles, a big die-cut cardstock centering ring, a sheet of pressure sensitive decals, and a 30" x 1/4" rubber shock cord. I bought the kit at Hobby Lobby in Killeen, Texas. All the parts were included in the kit--no broken ones were found.

Estes sent an update sheet with the instructions to replace the first three steps in the instruction sheet. It would not have gone together at all well if the original instructions had been followed. This rocket is as solidly built as any Estes product I have ever seen. The temptation to go back and get another one and build it for "E"-size motors is significant...

It was easy and quick to build. I started it at 8am and finished it except for paint by ten! I added an 18" length of 1/8" round elastic cord to the existing rubber band.

PROs: solid plastic parts, Estes on the ball with instruction update.

CONs: typical too short length of shock cord.

Finishing:
Rubicon has a slightly complicated multicolor paint scheme, but it's not really that bad. Lines between colors match up neatly with lines between parts. This model is well thought out to be fairly easy to paint too. I did most of mine with a brush and Testor's acrylics. I felt that the tank tubes were pictured as black and the nose cone and fins were pictured as red, so my paint scheme is not exactly as described.

I also prefer waterslide decals to the stickers Estes is using these days, as the waterslide decals can be positioned more easily than stickers with less risk of bubbles.

Construction Rating: 4 out of 5

Flight:
The Rubicon's recommended motors are the D12-3 and D12-5. I flew it on D12-3s.

It was easy to prepare for flight. Lots of parachute space in that 3.21" diameter main body tube! I stuffed four squares of Estes wadding down the motor mount tube and laid two more on top of it. The typical Estes motor retainer hook was the method used on the Rubicon.

If I had been a little more inclined to make minor modifications, I would have installed the shock cord differently. It seems to me that drilling two 1/4" holes in the uppermost centering ring and tying the cord there would result in a better setup than the usual paper mount.

Recovery:
Estes should make 20" parachutes. This rocket falls into the slot of too heavy for an 18" chute and not heavy enough for a 24" one. It is fortunately sturdy enough to land under an 18" chute and take no damage, even on concrete!

Flight Rating: 4 out of 5

Summary:
Another well-done X-Prize contender.

PROs: solid construction, excellent plastic parts, a headline-grabbing subject.

CONs: none worth mentioning.

Overall Rating: 4 out of 5

Flight Log

Comments:

D.W.M. (April 23, 2006)

I bought my son a Rubicon for his birthday last year and we've flown it several times. However, we use a 20" nylon parachute for recovery, and other than the usual breaking off of several fins on landing, works great. I modified the model to use the Estes E9-4 as well as the D12's.

B.S. (September 12, 2006)

While this rocket is good looking and fun to fly - it is poorly designed. The fins drop off like flies. I have tried multiple types of adhesives and nothing has worked. It isn't just a problem on landing - standing around the thing can suddenly lose a fin. I've actually lost a couple of the fins permanently now. I'm starting to think about modifying the rocket to use some type of bolt system (nylon) to hold the fins on.

M.S. (September 22, 2006)

Can you say Cluster Engine? Sure. I knew you could. This thing is just begging to be clustered!

A.P. (December 19, 2006)

This pictures of model looks great on line, but it seems to me that it's more show than go. It catches a lot of attention at the launch site, but at every launch, I lost a fin or two, even when mounted with epoxy. So after repairing and touching up the paint, it now sits on my son's shelf - where it looks great! Reminds me of the phrase, "better to look good than to(fly)good." If you do buy it, be sure to paint if before assembly.

- Post a Comment -

You must be logged into RocketReviews.com to post a comment.

What You Can Do

• Add a Link Related to this Review
• Submit a Kit Review

- Link to this Page -

You can link to this page using the following HTML or BB Code.

Text Link in HTML (for web sites)

<a href="http://www.rocketreviews.com/estes-industries-x-prize-rubicon-by-john-r-brandon-iii.html">Estes - X-Prize Rubicon - Review by John R. Brandon III</a>

Text Link in BB Code (for forum posts)

[url=http://www.rocketreviews.com/estes-industries-x-prize-rubicon-by-john-r-brandon-iii.html]Estes - X-Prize Rubicon - Review by John R. Brandon III[/url]

Select the appropriate above text with your mouse then "right-click" and select "Copy." Then, paste the text into your web site's code or a discussion forum post.