| Construction Rating: |      | | Flight Rating: |      | | Overall Rating: |      |
Contributed by Chan Stevens
Brief:
Robert Koenn has already submitted an excellent review for this, so I'll just add a few stray second opinions. This
is a great reproduction of the NASA/Aerojet research rocket and should appeal to both scale aficionados and NAR scale
competitors. At $30, it is a real bargain in the scale world.
Construction:
The kit is produced by BMS based upon the work of scale guru Peter Alway. As Robert noted, the parts are plentiful
and top notch quality. I'll also add that they are amazingly precise--perfect fits and no gaps. This brings the
complexity of construction down to the average modeler.
Construction begins with the fins, which are built up using 3 ribs and two outer skins. The end result is a highly
accurate reflection of the real rocket's recessed panels. The skins are almost transparently thin and they immediately
warped even when using a very light application of diluted Elmer's Fill 'n' Finish. This was easily resolved by
spending the night buried under a stack of heavy books (including, ironically, Rockets of The World). See photo
for a closer look at the fin construction.
The strap-on boosters are pure genius. You start with a pre-slotted body tube and 4 rings. The rings are from the
same tube, so therefore must be cut in order to fit around the booster tubes. The directions go to the detail to note
that if you cut across a spiral, the side visible will be spiral-free, eliminating the need to worry about the finish.
Now that's someone who understands the intricacies of scale craftsmanship! OK, so with the rings slipped over the
booster tube, you still have gaps from where you had to cut the rings to fit. No problem--the booster brackets that are
used to attach these to the main body tube are sized to exactly fill that gap. No seams, no spirals, and perfect fit.
The only minor blemish in appearance comes from the roll-your-own shroud, which invariably will show a seam although
the seam faces the small gap between the booster and main tube.
The main body tube has a number of slots for fit and alignment and even includes a couple marked lines
for lug placement. I skipped the lugs, as I intended to enter it in NAR competition and launch using either wrap-around
pop lugs or a piston to avoid losing points for non-scale lugs.
The nose cone assembly is hailed as the trickiest part of the construction. This is because there are four
fairings, which are made by gently folding and curling cardstock and bonding itty bitty side braces for mounting. It's
delicate work though being used to building Micromaxx sized rockets, I was up to the challenge. The fairings are bonded
with the assistance of a preprinted locator shroud/template.
As Robert noted, the motor mount is a bit unconventional. This is another handy technique designed to simplify
the complexity of scale construction, in this case the paint scheme. By permanently affixing the forward centering ring
and temporarily putting on the fins, you can get everything aligned then remove the fins for masking/painting.
Finishing:
Finishing is challenging but quite a bit easier thanks to the previous tip(s). The body is painted separately from
the booster tubes, starting with a couple primer coats then gloss white. Next, you mask off the top of the body tube
and white portion of the roll patterns, filling in with gloss black, and then mask off to paint the top 7/8" of
the body tube a "reddish brown", which I had to handle via mixing custom colors.
The booster tubes start out reddish brown at the top then gloss black for the bottom portion.
 
Once all the paint is dry, you can then attach the fins for real then the booster tubes and the aft centering
ring. Since the ring is bonded last, you also have a chance to paint it separately and get a nice finish as opposed to
the less than perfect finish you might typically expect on an aft ring prone to overspray and uneven finish.
There are a couple of silver trim decals that add the finishing touch.
Construction Rating:
5
out of 5
Flight:
The first flight was at an NAR regional competition on a breezy day. Winds were 8-12 mph, and the ground was rock
hard arid soil. I initially pulled out a D12-5 then thought I needed to be more conservative, so went with a C11-5. The
pop-lug was a little tight on the rod and probably contributed to slow speed as it cleared since it tipped over a bit
and went at about a 20 degree angle downwind. Robbed of altitude, the deployment was very late, roughly halfway back
down.
Recovery:
The kit comes with an 18" plastic chute, which is probably fine. Paranoid of the hard ground though, I swapped
out for a 24" nylon chute. The chute opened and held up pretty well but didn't have very long to slow things down
due to the late deploy. There was no serious damage, however, it did come down a bit hard and the soft balsa nose
suffered some competition-ending injuries--the cone tip was flattened and there were two small dents on the side. I
managed to pick up the last spare cone from BMS stock, so I can easily replace my slightly imperfect cone with a
perfect one in the future.
Overall, I think the wraparound lug and C11 was a bad combo. It should go up on a D12-5 and ideally lose the lug
entirely and stick with a piston.
Flight Rating:
3
out of 5
Summary:
I can't say enough about the quality of the parts and construction plan for this kit. It's an excellent reproduction
and greatly simplifies some potentially difficult aspects of the construction.
Overall Rating:
4
out of 5 Flight Log- Post a Comment -
eBay Offers: Saturn Press Flying Model Rocket Kit Astrobee 1500 >>> Product Details >>> Saturn Press 1/19 Scale Astrobee 1500 Kit NIB >>> Product Details >>>
What You Can Do
- Link to this Page -
You can link to this page using the following HTML or BB Code.
Text Link in HTML (for web sites)
<a href="http://www.rocketreviews.com/peter-alway-by-balsa-machining-service-astrobee-1500-by-chan-stevens.html">Saturn Press - Astrobee 1500 - Review by Chan Stevens</a>
Text Link in BB Code (for forum posts)
[url=http://www.rocketreviews.com/peter-alway-by-balsa-machining-service-astrobee-1500-by-chan-stevens.html]Saturn Press - Astrobee 1500 - Review by Chan Stevens[/url]
Select the appropriate above text with your mouse then "right-click" and select "Copy." Then, paste the text into your web site's code or a discussion forum post.
|