bannerbanner
Reviews >>

Semroc - Saturn 1B {Kit} (KS-1)

Published:2007-01-01
Manufacturer:Semroc
Diameter:3.9380 inches
Length:37.0000 inches
Skill Level:4
Style:Clone, Scale
Construction Rating:
Overall Rating:

Contributed by

Semroc Saturn 1B

Brief:
After teasing the rocketry community for nearly a year, Semroc finally released the reproduction 1/70th scale Saturn 1B just in time for Christmas. Faithfully reproduced based upon the 1967 Estes design (K-29), this kit is a very challenging but rewarding build. This is not for the faint hearted, nor for the rocketeer looking for a weekend project. Standard design calls for the original 4x18mm cluster although you can wimp out and use a 24mm single motor option as well.Don't expect it to be an exact match of the original though--the K-39 listed for $9.95 and currently fetches well above $100 on the open market today. The Semroc offering is available for a relatively modest $55.

Construction:
In a surprising break from the usual Semroc kit, this one comes in a box, not a bag. The reason for this is the extensive quantity of parts. The highlights of what you'll find unpacking the special box:

  • Apollo capsule kit
  • 8 BT-51 body tubes
  • BT-70 upper body tube
  • BT-100 main body tube
  • BT-101 fin can tube
  • 2 ST-990 inner tubes
  • 4 18mm motor tubes
  • 1 24mm motor tube (optional)
  • 5 embossed/corrugated wraps
  • Cardstock fin skins
  • Cardstock/glossy shroud
  • Laser-cut balsa fins, assorted details
  • Fiber centering rings, details
  • 32" plastic chute, elastic shock cord
  • Waterslide decals

Building this is quite a project, comparable in complexity to the Apogee Saturn 1B. The instructions are about 30 pages and nearly 100 steps. This is described as a skill level 4 kit and I would say it's at least that, if not a 5. The steps are clearly written and well illustrated so as long as you're careful, you can get through this build without major problems.

One feature to the kit I found to be very helpful: with a number of scaled dimensions getting down to the third decimal place and not exactly working to the nearest 1/16th or even 1/32nd of an inch, Semroc decided to include a preprinted ruler with every dimension already marked, including the construction step number. Now that's convenient!

Before beginning construction, it is essential that you thoroughly read all instructions first all the way through to the paint notes. I say this because if you build exactly as the instructions say, you'll find painting to be a pain and there are alternatives you can pursue along the way that make for a better finish.

Semroc Saturn 1B Then comes joining a pair of inside stuffer tubes (ST-990, roughly 24mm) using a coupler. Since the cluster or 24mm motor tube is designed to plug into this tube, a removable mount could be trickier than the typical SLS designs.

Next up is the 8-tube cluster assembly (these are not actual motor tube clusters as the actual 1B fired a full cluster). If you went with 4x18 motor cluster, 4 of the BT-51 tubes need to have slots cut out a bit to fit around the motor tubes. The cluster assembly starts with a couple of star-pattern centering rings mounted to the stuffer tube, followed by bonding the 8 BT-51 tubes in the corresponding slots in the centering rings. This is one of those steps where, once you've bonded the tubes, you'll be asking yourself, "How am I going to paint those alternating white and black?". I chose to paint my tubes first and bond later, however, that did require some creativity to retro-fit other painted details (I applied many of the techniques from the Apogee kit).

Semroc Saturn 1B The aft end of the 8-tube cluster is beefed up a bit with small ribs to which a BT-101 body tube is bonded. Just forward of the BT-101 you bond balsa fairing support pieces. These are a very helpful way to deal with bonding the rolled paper fairing shroud. After rolling/forming the fairing shroud, it slides down the tube assembly from above and bonds to the BT-101. This will be another point at which you're going to wonder how to mask off the black and white patterns plus deal with a potentially nasty seam between the fairing shroud and the BT-101. I wound up bonding my fin can, fins, and fairing shroud offline, painting, then fitting it in after bonding the 8 BT-51 tubes.

At the forward end of the stuffer tube, a couple of centering rings are attached to support the upper BT-70 body tube, which is also the main chute tube. First though, you slide one the BT-101 main body tubes until it slightly overlaps the fuel tanks.

The last of the body construction consists of rolling a cardstock shroud. The shroud has a glossy side, which is very handy if you happen to smear a little extra glue as it can be wiped off easily with a damp cloth.

There are a total of 5 embossed/corrugated wraps. It is best to apply a very thin smearing of white glue to the edges and pull them fairly tightly as you wrap them around the tubes. I found they fit extremely close--one was a little short and the others fit perfectly without trimming. Be sure to fill the tube spirals before applying the wraps though as this is tough to do once the wrap has been applied. Otherwise, you'll wind up sanding right up against the edge of the wrap.

Semroc Saturn 1B Your second construction choice comes regarding the fins. There are laser-cut 1/8" balsa fins, which are somewhat scale-like and happen to be the easy route. There is also a "built up fin" option made by assembling balsa ribs/frames, then wrapping skins over them. This built up approach is more difficult but offers a much better looking tapered fin. Obviously, if you're building a kit of this magnitude, you're no wimp, and the built-up fins are the only true option...

With the main construction done, it is now time to turn to the details. This is an amazing aspect of this kit and was a pleasant surprise for me (as I'd never built the original Estes). There are a good number of fiber details for tunnels, camera targets, antennae, sensors, latch pads, and covers. There is also a neat little technique for making the 3 discharge tubes. You start by cutting a launch lug at a tapered angle to serve as inner support, then wrap/glue a rolled pattern over it, and finally cutting away a small scallop. See photos for close-up of these and other details.

The last phase of the main rocket construction is the 4 service module nozzles. These are a pain to build but look pretty nice when complete. The main/center body is laser-cut balsa. That's the easy part. The hard part is the nozzles themselves, all 16 of them, cut from a wood dowel that's been cut to a taper via a pencil sharpener. 3/64" on one end and growing to 3/32" at the "fat" end, we're dealing very close to the sharpest tip of the point.

Semroc Saturn 1B If you've still got energy and ambition, you're ready for the finishing touch of the construction:building the Apollo capsule. See my Little Joe review for details on this. Suffice it to say I found this a very tedious and overly challenging build and will definitely be looking for a source of 0.041" and 0.058" diameter dowels/wire somewhere before building another Semroc Apollo capsule.

Finishing:
Painting Saturns is about as hard as rocket painting gets. You've got roll patterns, masking around corrugations, and if you followed the directions to letter, you'll find yourself masking over some awkward details.

I'm not going to get into a detailed rehashing of the paint scheme, but I will offer up some of the tips/techniques I applied to get a satisfactory finish.

First, the emphasis is on very light, very thin coats. I used flat white and flat black, which is unforgiving, so I couldn't pile on 4-5 coats without globbing over the corrugations. I used white primer, so could get by with just two base coats, sanding away most of the first one.

When masking, I let the base white coat dry for a full week then used the expensive low tack purple masking tape. Before applying the black, I shot one more light white coat so that it would seal off any miniscule gaps in the masking job. I then followed up with two coats of black.

For the occasional blemish, I was able to touch up using a black Sharpie, which was especially helpful sharpening lines along the corrugations.

Before bonding the details, I also checked the color scheme. It's a lot easier to paint a small fiber panel white then tack it on using CA, than it is to try ot mask it off and paint around it.

The finishing touches are the decals. They apply beautifully but are slightly glossy and therefore noticable against my flat background.

Semroc Saturn 1BSemroc Saturn 1B

Construction Rating: 5

Flight:
I'll hate to do this, but I wound up picking up two of these kits. The first one was built for display, not for flight, so the flight report is going to have to wait until I've had a chance to build the second one.

With the oversized fins, I have no doubt that this will be a stable flyer.

Summary:
I think I might need to update my Saturn comparative review, as this one definitely stands out in the crowded field. It's almost as detailed as the Apogee but nowhere near as expensive. It's about the same money as the Saturn Press (Peter Alway) Saturn V but much larger and offers more details, albeit it many you have to construct by hand. Overall, I'd have to say this is an even better bang for the buck than a Zooch and that's really saying something. Not that there's anything wrong with these other models (they're all outstanding kits), but this one is hands down the best balance of value and scale detail on the market.

The only con I can offer up the the overly difficult Apollo capsule. It's a good value (sells as a separate kit for $10 if you want a spare), but I'd much rather have dropped another $5 to avoid spending a couple hours sanding down dowels.

Overall Rating: 5

    Flight Log

    DateRocket NameMotor(s)AltitudeNotes
    2007-04-20Russell Garcia's Semroc Saturn 1B4XC6-3- First flight, absoulty perfect, looks great in flight. Very good kit to have. Can't beat the price
    2007-04-20Russell Garcia's Semroc Saturn 1B4XC6-3- Godd launch, chute improperly packed and fit too tightly in the tube, no ejection, nice nose dive ...
    2008-02-02Russell Garcia's Semroc Saturn 1B4XC6-3- Good launch and flight, parachute a little bit too small landed hard and broke a fin, will fly ...
    2008-02-10Shane Rhodes's Semroc Saturn 1B4xC6-3- Nice flight considering the wind with only a little weather cocking. Command module travelled out ...
    2008-03-02Russell Garcia's Semroc Saturn 1B4XC6-3- Good flight even with bad wiring job. Only two of the four motors lit.
    2008-03-08Russell Garcia's Semroc Saturn 1B4XC6-3- Fifth flight of my Semroc Saturn Ib. Good flight, soft landing, no damage
    2008-03-29Russell Garcia's Semroc Saturn 1B4XC6-3- Good flight, slight damage to fins on landing, repairable
    2008-04-06Russell Garcia's Semroc Saturn 1B4XC6-3- Good flight and recovery, no damage
    2008-05-26Russell Garcia's Semroc Saturn 1B4XC6-3- Good flight, broke fin on landing, nose cone landed in water and got wet and soggy, should dry out ...
    2009-03-28 Duane Boldt's Semroc Saturn 1B4XC6-3- This was an awesome 1st flight for this rocket. We were worried after all the build hours put into ...
    2009-09-07 Duane Boldt's Semroc Saturn 1B4XC6-3- Great flight. Has had great flights.
    2009-09-07 Duane Boldt's Semroc Saturn 1B4XC6-3- Great flight. Love the cluster of 4 motors!
    2009-09-07 Duane Boldt's Semroc Saturn 1B4XC6-3- Another perfect flight. Todays flights were for NARTREK Silver Level scale flights.
    2010-02-20Russell Garcia's Semroc Saturn 1B4XC6-3- Only three motors lit, shock cord burned through and rocket tumbled in, damaging two fins.
    2013-07-13Edward Chess's Semroc - Saturn 1B4XC6-3- Good boost, all motors lit. Event at apogee, but parachute did not eject from body. Freefall, ...
    2013-08-24 Mike Caplinger's Saturn IBE20-4- Nice first flight. Slow descent on main (53 seconds total flight time) and no damage apart from ...
    2013-09-28 Mike Caplinger's Saturn IBE20-4539 feet Nice flight; main chute a little melted.
    2014-01-25 Mike Caplinger's Saturn IBD12-3- Not a bad flight on the D12; slow liftoff and deployment near apogee.
    2014-01-25 Mike Caplinger's Saturn IBD12-3178 feet Another nice flight; broke one fin on landing and the main dragged the rocket 50 feet or so, no ...
    2014-03-01 John Bergsmith's Saturn 1BEstes C6-3- First flight, perfect. Recovered with no damage.
    2014-11-15 Mike Caplinger's Saturn IBE20-4- weathercocked a little; one shroud line broke on main chute and the CM's chute tangled in the LES ...
    2016-01-30 Mike Caplinger's Saturn IBD12-3- Arced a little in the wind, then weak ejection charge left main chute stuck in BT; rocket landed ...
    2016-02-27 Mike Caplinger's Saturn IBE12-4- A little wobbly on boost, good deploy. Duration 48 seconds. Broke two fins and LES tower on ...
    2017-11-28 Thomas Urban's Semroc Saturn 1BAerotech E20-4W- Beautiful flight, no damage
    2018-01-27 Mike Caplinger's Saturn IBE20-4- Jogged a little to the north after liftoff, landed in NW corner of field. One fin broke off; ...
    2018-04-11 Thomas Urban's Semroc Saturn 1BF-44-4W500 feet Good Flight, No issues

    Comments:

    D.W.M. (February 4, 2007)

    The Estes original Saturn 1-B is also packed inside a box.

    R.M.G. (March 8, 2008)

    Nice rocket to have, great price. Looks good on display, on the pad, and especially in flight. Just take your time building it.

    - Post a Comment -

    What You Can Do

    Recommended Motors: 4xC6-3, D12-3, D15-4

    Estes C6-3 Engine Pack (3-Each)
      >>> Product Details >>>

    Available from Amazon.com starting at US $10.43

    C6-3 Flight Pack - 3 Engines & igniters plus 12 sheets of wadding
      >>> Product Details >>>

    Available from Amazon.com starting at US $17.52

    ESTES 1566 D12-3 Std D Engine (2)
      >>> Product Details >>>

    Available from Amazon.com starting at US $7.71

    Launch Supplies:

    Estes 2274 Recovery Wadding
      >>> Product Details >>>

    Available from Amazon.com starting at US $4.39

    - Link to this Page -